Why the hourly rates cannot be compared directly
A contractor who charges $50 an hour looks far more expensive than an employee on $30 an hour. But the two numbers measure different things. The $50 is everything you pay the contractor. The $30 is only the start of what you pay for the employee.
On top of an employee's wage you pay employer payroll taxes, any benefits you offer, and the cost of finding and equipping them. To compare fairly, you need the employee's all-in cost per hour. That is what this calculator works out.
What an employee adds to your bill
- Social Security, 6.2% on wages up to $184,500 for 2026.
- Medicare, 1.45% on all wages.
- Federal unemployment tax (FUTA), usually 0.6% on the first $7,000 of wages.
- State unemployment tax (SUTA), at a rate and wage limit set by your state.
- Benefits, such as health insurance and a retirement match.
- One-off costs: recruiting, a laptop, training time.
With a contractor you pay none of these. You pay the invoice. The contractor covers their own taxes, insurance, tools and time off, which is why their rate is higher.
Example 1: a full-time, year-round role
Sam owns a marketing agency in Texas and needs a designer 40 hours a week all year. An employee would earn $30 an hour, with $500 a month toward health insurance and a 3% retirement match. A freelance designer quotes $50 an hour.
| For 2,080 hours | Cost |
|---|---|
| Employee wages | $62,400 |
| Employer payroll taxes | $5,059 |
| Benefits | $7,872 |
| Employee total | $75,331 |
| Contractor total ($50 × 2,080) | $104,000 |
The employee's all-in cost is $36.22 an hour, not $30. That is still well below $50, so the employee saves Sam $28,669 a year. The break-even rate is $36.22: a contractor would have to charge less than that to be the cheaper choice.
Example 2: a short project
Now Sam only needs help with one campaign: 20 hours a week for 12 weeks. Hiring an employee for that would also mean about $3,000 for recruiting, a laptop and setup.
| For 240 hours | Cost |
|---|---|
| Employee wages | $7,200 |
| Employer payroll taxes | $787 |
| Benefits | $1,601 |
| One-off hiring costs | $3,000 |
| Employee total | $12,588 |
| Contractor total ($50 × 240) | $12,000 |
Here the employee's all-in cost jumps to $52.45 an hour, because the hiring costs are spread over only 240 hours. The contractor is $588 cheaper, and Sam avoids hiring someone only to let them go three months later.
How to use the break-even rate
The break-even rate is the most useful number on this page. It turns the whole comparison into one figure you can hold against any quote.
- If a contractor quotes below the break-even rate, the contractor is the cheaper way to get those hours done.
- If the quote is above it, you are paying extra for flexibility. That can still be worth it when the work may dry up, or when you need a skill for a short time.
- If you are the one setting a contractor's pay, the break-even rate shows the most you can offer before an employee would cost less.
Change the weeks of work and watch the break-even rate move. The fewer hours you need, the higher it climbs, because fixed costs such as recruiting and equipment are spread over less work. That is why contractors suit small jobs and employees suit steady ones.
Costs the calculator cannot see
- Quiet weeks. An employee is paid whether or not there is work. A contractor is paid only for the hours you use.
- Management time. Employees need training, reviews and day-to-day direction.
- Knowledge that stays. An employee learns your business and gets faster. A contractor may not be available next time.
- Unemployment claims. If you let an employee go, a claim can raise your state unemployment tax rate for years.
- Workers' compensation insurance, which most states require for employees.
You cannot simply choose the label
This is the most important part of this page. Whether someone is a contractor or an employee is decided by how the work is really done, not by what your agreement calls them.
The IRS looks at three areas:
- Behavioral control. Do you decide how, when and where the work is done, or only the result?
- Financial control. Who pays for tools and expenses? Can the worker take other clients and make a profit or loss?
- The relationship. Is there a contract, are there benefits, and is the work ongoing and central to your business?
Someone who works set hours at your premises, uses your equipment and does the core work of your business is almost certainly an employee. States apply their own tests, and some, such as California, are stricter than the IRS.
If you treat an employee as a contractor, you can owe the unpaid payroll taxes, plus penalties and interest. When a case is unclear, ask an accountant or employment lawyer, or ask the IRS to decide using Form SS-8.
A simple way to decide
- Short, occasional or specialist work where the person controls how they do it: a contractor usually fits, and usually costs less.
- Ongoing, full-time, core work that you direct: an employee usually fits, and usually costs less per hour.
- In between: run both through the calculator, then check the classification rules before you choose the cheaper one.
Last updated: . Figures are for the 2026 tax year.